Oof, good one.
I’m currently using an Apple iPhone 4S on the Verizon network. Since I also own an iPad 2, it made sense to keep my app purchases within one ecosystem. I’ve become more and more of an Apple fan, and really enjoy the experience that the device brings. So, in that stance, i’m an Apple guy.
I will counter and say that I previously owned an HTC Droid Incredible, and am even testing a Motorola Droid RAZR as part of the VZW Ambassador program. Things such as Google Talk, and the ability to have notification profiles are things I miss from my Android device. The RAZR is the first 4G LTE device i’ve used, and the speed bump is significant (as is the battery drain).
In all honesty, either phone will deliver a very solid experience. I can’t declare the discussion as a one or the other, but I will say that both will meet the needs of the always-attached crowd.